SAMPLE
WINNOW PLUS™ QUARTERLY UPDATE
As
a Winnow Plus customer, you receive more frequent
searches of the IW database and immediate notification
of search results. IW reported the following
facts to you by telephone and email on the dates
indicated at the bottom of the report.
Broker
Name: Joseph V. Puschie
This
Broker Currently Works For:
Typical Brokerage, Inc.
Since
the last report, have we found out anything
else about him?
Mr. Puschie has moved from Ocala,
Florida to Boca Raton, Florida. Property records
show that he sold his home for $350,000 and
bought his new home for $750,000.
Since the last report he has
started a new business called, Financial Experts,
LLC, and registered as an Investment Adviser
(see glossary) with the SEC.
(1)
Yes. Mr. Puschie left Average Brokers, Inc.
in April 2007, and moved to Typical Brokerage,
Inc. NASD records indicated that he was terminated
by Average. By the time we send you your next
Winnow Plus report, more details of the circumstances
of the termination should be available.
(2) Yes. Since
the last report, the two arbitration actions
identified in earlier Winnow Plus reports have
been resolved. Each alleged that Mr. Puschie
engaged in churning, unauthorized trading, and
unsuitable trading (see glossary). Average settled
one of those actions for $150,000 (3)
and the other for $300,000
(4).
On July 1, 2007 the Certified
Financial Planning Board of Standards concluded
a disciplinary action against Mr. Puschie (5).
The CFP Board suspended Mr. Puschie for six
months, thereby denying him the right to use
the CFP designation for that period.
In light of these developments,
Investor’s Watchdog recommends that the customer
review her account carefully for signs of unauthorized
trading and/or churning and bring any problems
to the attention of the Typical compliance department
whose address is 123 Trust Avenue, Boston Massachusetts,
12345. If the customer needs legal advice, IW
can recommend an attorney experienced in such
matters. Call IW toll free at 866-423-WDOG (9364)
for a referral.
Since
the last report, has anything changed about
Mr. Puschie’s firm?
Mr. Puschie’s new firm, Typical,
is an independent broker-dealer headquartered
in Boston. Typical has been sanctioned numerous
times in the past ten years, and twice since
the last Winnow Plus report.
In June 2007, the U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission
issued a cease-and-desist order against Typical
for failure to give customers commission discounts
to which they were entitled. The SEC also fined
Typical $3 million.
In July 2007, the
NASD censured and fined Typical
$750,000 for failing to timely file 510 amendments
to Forms U4 and U5 which, if timely filed, would
have put the public on notice of 510 additional
regulatory actions or criminal actions by Typical
representatives.
(6)
In light of the forgoing, IW has lowered Mr.
Puschie’s IW score to
42 on a scale of 40 to 80. This
is a five point drop from the initial Broker
Safety Score of 47.
A score of 40 indicates a broker that, in IW’s
opinion, the client should avoid altogether.
A score of 80 indicates a broker who has been
tested by bear markets and yet has no customer
complaints, no disciplinary history, no negative
information in the IW database, and no areas
that raise concern for a former SEC Enforcement
Branch Chief.
(1) Facts reported
to the customer by telephone and email on April
10, 2007.
(2) Facts reported
to the customer by telephone and email on May
2, 2007.
(3) Facts reported
to the customer by telephone and email on June
6, 2007.
(4) Facts reported
to the customer by telephone and email on June
29, 2007.
(5) Facts reported
to the customer by telephone and email on July
1, 2007.
(6)
IW rates brokers on a 40 to 80 scale with a
higher score reflecting IW’s opinion, based
on historical information, that the investor’s
assets are safe from intentional or reckless
misconduct by the broker or his firm. IW expresses
no opinion on the value of the customer’s investments
or on the broker’s investment selection ability.
A single new fact can radically change the IW
score and indicate a need for immediate action.
For timelier notification of red flags, please
consider upgrading to IW’s Constant Patrol™
subscription.